运行规则,可以亲自核对

跟随一条决定的去向。

示例回放 · Review Kit 规则
允许试运行,执行完成,评价确认
  1. 记录提案

    提案等待审查。此时没有批准,也没有执行。

    查看记录
    {
      "kind": "review_proposal",
      "id": "proposal-approved",
      "at": "2026-09-18T09:00:00.000Z",
      "candidate_ref": "workflow:creative-review",
      "version": 1,
      "reason": "Try an explicit confirmation step before applying a suggested edit.",
      "status": "review_pending",
      "content_hash": "sha256:8a5600e85cbbf20e8eb9eff296d22b1b67745864b5a81317e28d8b31f01e4a08"
    }
  2. 独立的人工决定

    审查者允许有限试运行,这不等于结果成功。

    查看记录
    {
      "kind": "review_decision",
      "id": "decision-approved",
      "at": "2026-09-18T09:01:00.000Z",
      "proposal_ref": "proposal-approved",
      "proposal_hash": "sha256:8a5600e85cbbf20e8eb9eff296d22b1b67745864b5a81317e28d8b31f01e4a08",
      "candidate_ref": "workflow:creative-review",
      "candidate_version": 1,
      "decided_by": "local_user",
      "status": "authorized_for_trial",
      "content_hash": "sha256:407589f684e2d6b36ab8902fd4f1ba374ee9ba302632138877515d2a4773c876"
    }
  3. 执行拥有独立结果

    执行记录说明操作已完成,不代表产品质量得到确认。

    查看记录
    {
      "kind": "execution_receipt",
      "id": "execution-approved",
      "at": "2026-09-18T09:02:00.000Z",
      "decision_ref": "decision-approved",
      "decision_hash": "sha256:407589f684e2d6b36ab8902fd4f1ba374ee9ba302632138877515d2a4773c876",
      "candidate_ref": "workflow:creative-review",
      "status": "executed",
      "change_ref": "change:synthetic-example",
      "content_hash": "sha256:82112bcb808f320146ebfbba53365228857e1dcaf6b122a9094198df63ca3398"
    }
  4. 评价证据

    示例中提供的信号满足确认规则。

    查看记录
    {
      "kind": "evaluation_result",
      "id": "evaluation-approved",
      "at": "2026-09-18T09:03:00.000Z",
      "execution_ref": "execution-approved",
      "execution_hash": "sha256:82112bcb808f320146ebfbba53365228857e1dcaf6b122a9094198df63ca3398",
      "candidate_ref": "workflow:creative-review",
      "status": "confirmed",
      "evidence_complete": true,
      "checks_passed": true,
      "regression_found": false,
      "content_hash": "sha256:3dca0e1c4d5a60b59cfd8957db0b9f7116de484cce6cc2dcc225ef7c87b99a2a"
    }
拒绝提案,阻止执行
  1. 记录提案

    提案等待审查。此时没有批准,也没有执行。

    查看记录
    {
      "kind": "review_proposal",
      "id": "proposal-rejected",
      "at": "2026-09-18T09:00:00.000Z",
      "candidate_ref": "workflow:creative-review",
      "version": 1,
      "reason": "Try an explicit confirmation step before applying a suggested edit.",
      "status": "review_pending",
      "content_hash": "sha256:54ff9008680878490a48a635b6e41faa28bd575e8310dae32475a79f8d7156a6"
    }
  2. 独立的人工决定

    审查者拒绝本次试运行。

    查看记录
    {
      "kind": "review_decision",
      "id": "decision-rejected",
      "at": "2026-09-18T09:01:00.000Z",
      "proposal_ref": "proposal-rejected",
      "proposal_hash": "sha256:54ff9008680878490a48a635b6e41faa28bd575e8310dae32475a79f8d7156a6",
      "candidate_ref": "workflow:creative-review",
      "candidate_version": 1,
      "decided_by": "local_user",
      "status": "rejected",
      "content_hash": "sha256:233b373c1becf6683b02a2844cb66ec85996433758a6e3e8565b0715bd1498be"
    }
  3. 执行被阻止

    模块拒绝根据已拒绝的决定创建执行记录。

    查看记录
    {
      "kind": "blocked_attempt",
      "code": "TRIAL_NOT_AUTHORIZED"
    }
执行失败,如实保留
  1. 记录提案

    提案等待审查。此时没有批准,也没有执行。

    查看记录
    {
      "kind": "review_proposal",
      "id": "proposal-failed",
      "at": "2026-09-18T09:00:00.000Z",
      "candidate_ref": "workflow:creative-review",
      "version": 1,
      "reason": "Try an explicit confirmation step before applying a suggested edit.",
      "status": "review_pending",
      "content_hash": "sha256:adfe434a3da6c2f4488c5d95bba4e257428dae647d493ba75cb0a392f8589652"
    }
  2. 独立的人工决定

    审查者允许有限试运行,这不等于结果成功。

    查看记录
    {
      "kind": "review_decision",
      "id": "decision-failed",
      "at": "2026-09-18T09:01:00.000Z",
      "proposal_ref": "proposal-failed",
      "proposal_hash": "sha256:adfe434a3da6c2f4488c5d95bba4e257428dae647d493ba75cb0a392f8589652",
      "candidate_ref": "workflow:creative-review",
      "candidate_version": 1,
      "decided_by": "local_user",
      "status": "authorized_for_trial",
      "content_hash": "sha256:0c13d6cc93cb0c35efa0d5119863c1ebda2f60343018788473c5a33f7a581967"
    }
  3. 执行拥有独立结果

    如实保留执行失败,不改写之前的决定。

    查看记录
    {
      "kind": "execution_receipt",
      "id": "execution-failed",
      "at": "2026-09-18T09:02:00.000Z",
      "decision_ref": "decision-failed",
      "decision_hash": "sha256:0c13d6cc93cb0c35efa0d5119863c1ebda2f60343018788473c5a33f7a581967",
      "candidate_ref": "workflow:creative-review",
      "status": "execution_failed",
      "change_ref": "change:synthetic-example",
      "content_hash": "sha256:938dd4a03c4c16e257a65842ff16fb416fe7bb0acd00ee9be6f1e3ca8399d4d4"
    }
  4. 评价证据

    现有证据不足以确认,评价保留为不确定。

    查看记录
    {
      "kind": "evaluation_result",
      "id": "evaluation-failed",
      "at": "2026-09-18T09:03:00.000Z",
      "execution_ref": "execution-failed",
      "execution_hash": "sha256:938dd4a03c4c16e257a65842ff16fb416fe7bb0acd00ee9be6f1e3ca8399d4d4",
      "candidate_ref": "workflow:creative-review",
      "status": "inconclusive",
      "evidence_complete": false,
      "checks_passed": false,
      "regression_found": false,
      "content_hash": "sha256:aea45a6dc7e34ad691ee50c80ca498b0640115cf698cd92acaa0dacd1f246304"
    }
执行完成,证据仍然不足
  1. 记录提案

    提案等待审查。此时没有批准,也没有执行。

    查看记录
    {
      "kind": "review_proposal",
      "id": "proposal-uncertain",
      "at": "2026-09-18T09:00:00.000Z",
      "candidate_ref": "workflow:creative-review",
      "version": 1,
      "reason": "Try an explicit confirmation step before applying a suggested edit.",
      "status": "review_pending",
      "content_hash": "sha256:75498a88e2cbf7aaf63c75a94a7c851008af57bfd275df673b7716fb09f5d5f1"
    }
  2. 独立的人工决定

    审查者允许有限试运行,这不等于结果成功。

    查看记录
    {
      "kind": "review_decision",
      "id": "decision-uncertain",
      "at": "2026-09-18T09:01:00.000Z",
      "proposal_ref": "proposal-uncertain",
      "proposal_hash": "sha256:75498a88e2cbf7aaf63c75a94a7c851008af57bfd275df673b7716fb09f5d5f1",
      "candidate_ref": "workflow:creative-review",
      "candidate_version": 1,
      "decided_by": "local_user",
      "status": "authorized_for_trial",
      "content_hash": "sha256:a8f062759c7be8a3528c0bffc04c193c094822440a1fd3ed7067eb5c70400476"
    }
  3. 执行拥有独立结果

    执行记录说明操作已完成,不代表产品质量得到确认。

    查看记录
    {
      "kind": "execution_receipt",
      "id": "execution-uncertain",
      "at": "2026-09-18T09:02:00.000Z",
      "decision_ref": "decision-uncertain",
      "decision_hash": "sha256:a8f062759c7be8a3528c0bffc04c193c094822440a1fd3ed7067eb5c70400476",
      "candidate_ref": "workflow:creative-review",
      "status": "executed",
      "change_ref": "change:synthetic-example",
      "content_hash": "sha256:6ef722d4e4726a926bf28b875dbaf78e79109ea0ca187813ec280a0a5c09bb78"
    }
  4. 评价证据

    现有证据不足以确认,评价保留为不确定。

    查看记录
    {
      "kind": "evaluation_result",
      "id": "evaluation-uncertain",
      "at": "2026-09-18T09:03:00.000Z",
      "execution_ref": "execution-uncertain",
      "execution_hash": "sha256:6ef722d4e4726a926bf28b875dbaf78e79109ea0ca187813ec280a0a5c09bb78",
      "candidate_ref": "workflow:creative-review",
      "status": "inconclusive",
      "evidence_complete": false,
      "checks_passed": false,
      "regression_found": false,
      "content_hash": "sha256:9b2f342354b9ff6922be283e176161e371e81726506eb5611ee443beecfee2e2"
    }

从记录中看见边界

模块从较大的本地工作台中提取审查概念,整理成独立实现。它不访问私人账本,也不调用模型。它包含内部工作台 62 条确定性测试中的 14 条。模块函数生成四组回放:允许并通过、拒绝后阻止执行、执行失败,以及执行完成但证据不足。

在本机运行

安装 Node.js 20 或更新版本,解压源码包或克隆仓库并进入目录。运行过程不需要额外依赖。

node --test tests/*.test.mjs
node examples/run.mjs
node scripts/export-scenarios.mjs scenarios.json

公开接口

记录职责
ReviewProposal说明候选与修改原因
ReviewDecision允许试运行、拒绝或延期
ExecutionReceipt记录允许之后的执行结果
EvaluationResult区分确认、回归与不确定

有意保持的限制

角色字段无法认证身份,内容哈希无法充当数字签名。模块不提供持久化、并发事务、防重放或真实权限控制。评价输入来自调用方判断,模块不会自动运行模型评测。reverted 记录评价结论,不能自行回滚外部系统。

README、运行时检查和测试均明确说明这些边界。本模块已开源于 GitHub,并提供离线归档包供本地审阅。